SUPREME COURT TO HEAR PLEAS CHALLENGING CEC GYANESH KUMAR’S FUNCTIONING AND SPECIAL INTENSIVE REVISION DECISIONS

The Supreme Court of India is scheduled to hear two petitions raising significant constitutional and institutional questions concerning the functioning of Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar and the Election Commission of India’s Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.

The matters are listed before a three-judge Bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana. The petitions seek judicial scrutiny of alleged unilateral decision-making within the Election Commission and challenge various decisions and measures associated with the SIR exercise.

Background: The SIR Controversy

The Special Intensive Revision is an exercise undertaken by the Election Commission to undertake a comprehensive revision and verification of electoral rolls. Such exercises are intended to ensure that electoral rolls accurately reflect eligible voters while removing entries that do not satisfy the statutory requirements.

However, the present litigation raises a broader question: how should the constitutional authority of the Election Commission operate when the Commission is a multi-member constitutional body?

The petitions reportedly challenge a series of decisions and directions concerning the SIR exercise, alleging that certain decisions were taken in the name of the Election Commission without the concurrence of the other Election Commissioners.

According to reports cited in the petitions, Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi had recorded objections on multiple occasions concerning decisions 2 connected with the SIR process. The petitions allege that at least 14 such objections were recorded between October 2025 and August 2026. These allegations remain subject to judicial examination and should not be treated as established findings against the CEC.

What Are the Petitioners Seeking?

The petitions reportedly seek a range of reliefs, including judicial examination of whether decisions taken in the name of the Election Commission were constitutionally and legally authorised.

Among the reliefs sought are:

• Examination of whether the Chief Election Commissioner could independently exercise powers vested in the Election Commission as a multi-member constitutional body;

• Challenge to decisions and directions allegedly taken without the concurrence of the other Election Commissioners;

• Judicial scrutiny of certain SIR-related decisions;

• An independent inquiry/Special Investigation Team into the allegations concerning the electoral-roll exercise;

• Suspension of the CEC pending final adjudication; and

• Examination of alleged changes concerning electoral-roll procedures and Form 6 requirements.

The Court, however, has not at this stage made any finding that the allegations against the CEC are established.

Constitutional Position of the Election Commission

The Election Commission of India derives its constitutional authority principally from Article 324 of the Constitution.

Article 324 vests in the Election Commission the superintendence, direction and control of elections to Parliament, State Legislatures, and the offices of President and Vice-President.

The constitutional design therefore places the Election Commission in a position of considerable institutional importance. Its independence and credibility are closely connected with the constitutional requirement of conducting elections in a manner that is free and fair.

The present proceedings consequently raise an important institutional question: whether the authority conferred upon the Election Commission can be exercised by one member independently where the constitutional and statutory framework contemplates a multimember Commission.

This issue is distinct from determining whether the SIR itself is legally permissible.

SIR and the Electoral Roll: The Legal Framework

The preparation and revision of electoral rolls operate within the framework of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, together with the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 and constitutional provisions concerning elections.

Articles 325 and 326 of the Constitution are particularly relevant.

Article 325

Article 325 establishes the principle of a general electoral roll and prohibits exclusion from electoral rolls on grounds such as religion, race, caste or sex.

Article 326

Article 326 provides for elections to the Lok Sabha and State Legislative Assemblies on the basis of adult suffrage, subject to constitutionally recognised disqualifications.

Consequently, electoral-roll revision involves a delicate balance:

On one side: ensuring that electoral rolls are accurate and do not contain ineligible or duplicate entries.

On the other: ensuring that eligible citizens are not wrongly excluded from the democratic process.

This balance assumes particular significance where large-scale revision of electoral rolls is undertaken.

Right to Vote and Constitutional Protection

The Supreme Court has repeatedly clarified that the right to vote is not a fundamental right in the conventional sense. Nevertheless, the right to vote and participate in elections is firmly embedded within the constitutional and statutory electoral framework.

In People’s Union for Civil Liberties v. Union of India, the Supreme Court recognised the constitutional significance of the electoral process and the voter’s right within the framework of Article 326.

The Court has also emphasised that electoral democracy requires transparency and procedural fairness.

More recently, in Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023), the Supreme Court examined the constitutional framework concerning the appointment of members of the Election Commission and emphasised the importance of institutional independence in protecting the integrity of the electoral process.

These principles provide an important constitutional backdrop to the present litigation.

Procedural Safeguards Against Deletion of Voters

An important dimension of electoral-roll revision is the procedure followed before deleting an existing elector from the electoral roll.

The Supreme Court has previously stressed the importance of notice and an opportunity of hearing before deletion of an existing voter’s name, subject to recognised exceptions.

In Lal Babu Hussain v. Electoral Registration Officer, the Court dealt with safeguards surrounding deletion from electoral rolls and underscored the significance of procedural fairness.

This principle becomes particularly important when electoral-roll revision involves a substantial number of voters. A technically valid power of revision cannot be divorced from the requirement that the procedure used to exercise that power remains fair, transparent and consistent with law.

The Institutional Question: Can a Multi-Member Commission Act Unilaterally?

One of the most consequential questions raised by the present petitions concerns the decision making structure of the Election Commission.

The Election Commission is not constitutionally designed merely as the personal office of the Chief Election Commissioner. Article 324 establishes the Election Commission as the constitutional authority responsible for electoral administration.

The petitioners therefore contend that decisions taken in the Commission’s name must comply with the constitutional and statutory decision-making framework applicable to the institution as a whole.

The precise legal position, however, will depend upon the Court’s interpretation of:

1. Article 324 of the Constitution;

2. The Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners Act, 2023;

3. Rules and procedures governing the transaction of business by the Commission;

4. The legal status of decisions allegedly taken without concurrence of other Election Commissioners; and

5. The extent of judicial review available against decisions of an independent constitutional authority.

These are questions of institutional constitutional law rather than merely administrative disagreements between officeholders.

Judicial Review of Election Commission Decisions

The Election Commission enjoys substantial constitutional autonomy, but that autonomy does not place its actions beyond judicial scrutiny.

The Supreme Court has historically exercised judicial review where electoral authorities are alleged to have acted contrary to constitutional provisions, statutory requirements or principles of fairness.

At the same time, courts ordinarily exercise considerable institutional restraint in matters falling within the specialised electoral domain.

The present proceedings may therefore require the Court to maintain a careful constitutional balance between:

Electoral autonomy + institutional independence + judicial review + protection of democratic participation.

Why the Case Matters

The significance of the litigation extends beyond the immediate allegations concerning the CEC.

1. Institutional independence of the Election Commission

The proceedings may clarify the respective constitutional and statutory roles of the CEC and other Election Commissioners in a multi-member Commission.

2. Validity of SIR-related decisions

The Court may be required to examine whether disputed decisions concerning electoral-roll revision were taken in accordance with the applicable legal framework.

3. Protection of eligible voters

The case raises concerns about the procedural safeguards required before an eligible elector is removed from the electoral roll.

4. Limits of constitutional discretion

The proceedings may further clarify how far constitutional authorities can exercise administrative discretion and what procedural safeguards remain mandatory.

5. Electoral integrity

Ultimately, the legitimacy of an electoral system depends not merely upon holding elections but upon maintaining public confidence that the electoral rolls are prepared and revised through lawful, transparent and non-arbitrary procedures.

SIR and the Supreme Court’s Earlier Position

The present proceedings should also be viewed against the backdrop of the Supreme Court’s earlier adjudication concerning the SIR exercise.

The Court had previously upheld the Election Commission’s authority to conduct the SIR exercise in its 27 May 2026 judgment, although the present petitions raise additional questions concerning the functioning of the Commission and alleged decision-making processes.

Therefore, the current litigation does not necessarily amount to a simple re-opening of the legality of SIR as a concept. Instead, an important part of the controversy concerns how particular decisions were made and whether the constitutional and statutory decisionmaking requirements were followed.

Conclusion

The Supreme Court’s hearing on 5 October 2026 places the functioning of India’s electoral machinery under significant constitutional scrutiny.

The central questions extend beyond the immediate controversy surrounding Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. They concern the institutional structure of the Election Commission, the legality of decision-making within a multi-member constitutional body, safeguards governing electoral-roll revision, and the protection of citizens’ participation in representative democracy.

The allegations raised in the petitions remain matters for judicial determination. The outcome could nevertheless have important implications for the future functioning of the Election Commission and for the legal standards governing large-scale electoral-roll revisions.

For a constitutional democracy, the integrity of the electoral process depends upon two equally important principles: accurate electoral rolls and lawful protection of every eligible voter’s participation. The Supreme Court’s examination of these issues may therefore become significant not only for the present SIR controversy but also for the institutional jurisprudence governing India’s electoral process.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top